Determining the Scope

Home
The Issue
Initial Discovery
Determining the Scope
The Test Procedure
1394 Spec - Comparison
What to Do
Communications
Current Status
Reference Materials


In the days following our discovery, we went back to FunKey Computers in Bellevue
, WA (now out of business) and explained the problem to them.  They provided us with two, brand new cases still shrink-wrapped in the box.  We verified that the defect also existed in those cases.  We then went down the road to Computer Stop where we tested one case, and then to PC Club where we tested another brand-new case.  All Xaser III cases we tested were defective.  During this testing, we came up with a fairly quick way to test for the defect.  That procedure is discussed in the next section.  In the days that followed our testing, it became clear that the problem was not limited to a particular lot destined for the Pacific Northwest.  The problem's just weird enough that most people assume they did something wrong, not Thermaltake.  Further, the problem will only be seen by people who actually use the 1394 socket, which means they have a relatively new motherboard that offers the pins necessary to connect the 1394 port on the case - and they'll either have to connect a bus-powered FireWire device or a device that uses a 6-pin to 4-pin FireWire cable before the damage occurs.

Conditions necessary to be affected by this defect

  1. The customer purchased a Thermaltake Xaser III PC case (any color or style), or any of the similar cases created by the same OEM as described on the home page.
  2. The customer installs a motherboard with an on-board 1394 header that will allow connection of the top 1394 socket, such as the Asus A7N8X Deluxe motherboard.
  3. The customer decides to use the top 1394 socket instead of the back-plane connector supplied by the motherboard manufacturer.
  4. The customer correctly wires the case 1394 socket to the motherboard, making sure each signal on the motherboard correctly matches the printed signal name on the 1394 cable - Pin for Pin.
  5. The customer connects a BUS-POWERED 1394 device to the top connector using a standard 6-pin cable, such as a FireWire Web Camera or a small, bus-powered portable hard drive or they use a 6-pin to 4-pin 1394 cable and connect a device such as a Creative Nomad Zen or Jukebox 3.  "Regular", non-bus powered devices such as external CD-R enclosures or any other devices which use either a power supply or AC directly from the wall may not be affected by this problem since the 1394 socket power supply pins are not usually used with these devices (they aren't connected internally to the device since the device's built-in power supply is used instead).

 

Home | The Issue | Communications | Current Status | Reference Materials

As of 12/2005, this site is for reference purposes only and is no longer maintained.
Copyright (C) 2005 Meltybrain and Co., All rights reserved.  Thermaltake is a trademark of Thermaltake Technology Co., Ltd.
The term "FireWire" is a registered trademark of Apple Computer, Inc.  All other registered trademarks belong to their respective companies.

Last modified: 12/23/05.