The Test Procedure

Home
The Issue
Initial Discovery
Determining the Scope
The Test Procedure
1394 Spec - Comparison
What to Do
Communications
Current Status
Reference Materials


Test Theory

             The purpose of the following test procedure is to eliminate any chance for human error when determining whether or not the Thermaltake Xaser III 1394 is correctly wired or not, as well as to eliminate the possibility that the person installing the 1394 cable harness to the motherboard did so correctly.  This procedure basically relies on the assumption that the 1394 hub used below is manufactured correctly and provides bus power and signal on the correct 1394 pins per the 1394 socket specification.  During the test, positive voltage from the hub will be transferred out of the hub via pin 1 of the attached 1394 cable to pin 1 of the 1394 socket on the Xaser III.  This positive voltage will then be transferred through the 1394 socket down to the wires that would normally attach to the installed mother board.  In this, you should be able to measure the POSITIVE voltage on the wire labeled "VP" for "Volts Positive".

 Test Tool and Peripheral Requirements

bullet

1 multi-meter capable of measuring up to 50VDC.

bullet

1 Self-powered (via AC adapter) stand-alone 1394 hub, such as the Belkin 4-Port Hub model number F5U524.  Technically, any known good 1394 host adapter that provides bus power via a 6-pin 1394 socket  can be used as a substitute for the 1394 hub.

bullet

1 Thermaltake Xaser III computer case

bullet

1 Standard Firewire cable (6 pin to 6 pin)

 Test Procedure

  1. Plug in the standalone Firewire hub and verify that it is energized.

  2.  Ensure the Xaser III motherboard cable that connects the top 1394 socket is not connected to any device inside the case.  Locate the single wire female pins from the top 1394 case connector cable labeled VG and VP (Voltage GROUND and Voltage POSITIVE).  The two USB headers are also part of this same cable but are not used in any way during this test and should remain disconnected.

  3. Connect the 6-Pin standard 1394 cable from the powered FireWire hub to the top 1394 socket on the Xaser III case.  This sends bus power from the hub through the Thermaltake 1394 interface and down the cable to the VG and VP pins.

  4. Using the Multi-meter, connect the POSITIVE test lead to the exposed side of the VP pin and then connect the NEGATIVE test lead to the exposed side of the VG pin.  You should see POSITIVE voltage on the Multi-meter display, indicating that the pins are correctly labeled.  If you see NEGATIVE voltage, such as -12 Volts on the Multi-meter, and you have verified that the Multi-meter POSITIVE lead is attached to the VP pin and the Multi-meter NEGATIVE lead is attached to the VG pin, you are affected by this wiring defect and use of this 1394 socket with a bus-powered FireWire device or any device that uses a 6-pin to 4-pin FireWire cable will either short out and destroy the FireWire device, the mainboard 1394 controller chip, or both.  In all test cases seen thus far, the damage done to the devices has been permanent.

The potential damage caused by this defect could be far more massive than this document suggests, and you should not assume that damage caused by this defect will only be limited to the peripheral and/or motherboard.  Example:  If a user were to connect his two high-end, expensive PC's together to utilize Microsoft Windows 1394 Networking capability, the direct short caused by this defect could translate past the 1394 controller chips and potentially damage other non-1394 devices in both computers, as well as the power supply in each computer.  In some cases, the 1394 controller chip may get hot enough to actually start to burn and release smoke.

 

Home | The Issue | Communications | Current Status | Reference Materials

As of 12/2005, this site is for reference purposes only and is no longer maintained.
Copyright (C) 2005 Meltybrain and Co., All rights reserved.  Thermaltake is a trademark of Thermaltake Technology Co., Ltd.
The term "FireWire" is a registered trademark of Apple Computer, Inc.  All other registered trademarks belong to their respective companies.

Last modified: 12/23/05.